What this actually measures
Every player taken is ranked by 2025 PPR, then compared to where he went. Positive value means a manager got someone later than last season’s production deserved. It scores who fell, not who was right — the 2026 season has not been played. 17 rookies and defences have no prior year and are excluded rather than scored as zero.
| # | Manager | Best pick | Worst pick | Rated | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Devin Johnny Broken Dreams | Trevor Lawrence 12.04 · QB · +104 | Cam Little 10.04 · K · −37 | 14 of 15 | +295 |
| 2 | Audrey Waddle Baby Waddle | Wan'Dale Robinson 12.08 · WR · +75 | Kenneth Walker 3.03 · RB · −39 | 14 of 15 | +178 |
| 3 | Jason I'm Sorry Smith Jaxon | Justin Herbert 12.10 · QB · +99 | Garrett Wilson 5.01 · WR · −75 | 14 of 15 | +131 |
| 4 | Rohit rohit's Great Team | Kyle Monangai 14.03 · RB · +44 | Ladd McConkey 6.03 · WR · −20 | 13 of 15 | +95 |
| 5 | Adam Love a Cook Mixon up some Lamb | Patrick Mahomes 13.06 · QB · +104 | Malik Nabers 3.06 · WR · −97 | 13 of 15 | +94 |
| 6 | Maria Tortured Butt(ker) Department | Zach Charbonnet 15.02 · RB · +70 | Omarion Hampton 3.02 · RB · −74 | 14 of 15 | +73 |
| 7 | Mom Whiskey's Warriors | Juwan Johnson 15.10 · TE · +76 | Brandon Aubrey 8.01 · K · −54 | 12 of 15 | +46 |
| 8 | Sean Ball Knower | Deebo Samuel 15.05 · WR · +81 | Tucker Kraft 6.06 · TE · −52 | 13 of 15 | +44 |
| 9 | Sug The greatest team ever | Jaxson Dart 12.02 · QB · +80 | Cam Skattebo 4.02 · RB · −72 | 14 of 15 | −15 |
| 10 | Alec Jerry Jones' Diary | Rico Dowdle 11.04 · RB · +59 | Jayden Daniels 5.04 · QB · −66 | 12 of 15 | −177 |
The five that fell furthest
Everybody let these go
- +104Trevor LawrenceQB · taken 12.04 by Devin
- +104Patrick MahomesQB · taken 13.06 by Adam
- +99Justin HerbertQB · taken 12.10 by Jason
- +98Bo NixQB · taken 12.05 by Adam
- +97Stefon DiggsWR · taken 15.07 by Devin